Still trying to wrap my head around REST, and have a question for the lazyweb. Suppose my app contains users and groups, with a many-to-many relationship between them (i.e., a user can belong to any number of groups, and a group can contain any number of users. I can identify users as /app/user/fred, /app/user/jane, etc., and use GET/POST/PUT/DELETE to fetch, create, update, and delete. (Yeah, I know, GPPD != CRUD, but you get the idea.) I can similarly use /app/project/red and /app/project/green to identify projects, but what should I use to identify memberships? /app/project/green/user/fred? Nope: it mixes category identifiers ('project', 'user') and item identifiers ('green', 'fred'), and more importantly, implies that users are sub-categories of projects---it would be just as logical to use /app/user/fred/project/green, which means that both are probably wrong.
In the relational database world, of course, many-to-many relationships are almost always represented by introducing new entities, such as a tuple <<17238917, 'fred', 'green'>> (where 17238917 is a magic number created by the system for its own use, and not exposed to the outside world). Is that the right way to do many-to-many in REST? I.e., should /app/membership/17238917 return the pair <<'fred', 'green'>>, while /app/project/green/members returns a list of magic membership tuple IDs, and /app/user/fred/groups returns ditto? What's the right (or at least most common) way to do this?
comments powered by Disqus